Next Tottenham v Ipswich TownSat 21 Nov, 15:00

Tottenham is widely believed to be a managerial graveyard for any aspiring coach. The club has had 10 different people in charge across the last decade, and has long been seen as a poisoned chalice among the big jobs in club football.

Indeed, even the most storied coaches have largely failed at Spurs: José Mourinho’s and Antonio Conte’s tenures were both short-lived, and both ended in bitter separations. Daniel Levy can’t even be solely blamed for this pattern. Vinai Venkatesham has overseen three head coaches in the last 12 months; if anything, he has seen more turnover in a shorter time than his predecessor.

Like most managerial tenures, the departures are often the result of perceived failure and underperformance. The exceptions at Spurs are Mauricio Pochettino and Ange Postecoglou, and even they are remembered for the highs of their reigns rather than the position the club was in when they were dismissed.

Yet a firing from Spurs doesn’t seem to mean banishment to the footballing wilderness. In fact, it seems to be quite the opposite.

Conte and Mourinho had the reputations to go almost anywhere, ending up at Napoli and Roma respectively. Pochettino delivered enough at Spurs to merit jobs at the highest level: PSG, Chelsea, the USMNT and now Manchester United have all followed.

But it goes far beyond this. Tim Sherwood’s comedy show at Spurs somehow landed him the Aston Villa job. Nuno’s sorry episode earned him a lucrative gig at Al-Ittihad, followed by Premier League stints at Nottingham Forest and, most recently, West Ham. André Villas-Boas went on to desirable roles at Zenit St Petersburg and Marseille. Yet nothing will surpass the bemusement of Spurs fans when Thomas Frank was announced as Crystal Palace manager this week.

Not only did Frank leave Spurs teetering above the relegation zone, he also oversaw the most desperate and miserable chapter of football in the club’s recent history. The tongue-in-cheek apologies to Palace fans on social media show the wider footballing community just how deplorable his tenure was, even if they didn’t have to sit through it week in, week out.

Personal grievances against Frank aside, there does still appear to be a pattern of career rebounds following failure at Spurs. Why is this?

Many in football have rightly perceived Spurs as a hard place to succeed: uneven recruitment, sudden changes of direction and squad profile, and, historically, having to deal with Daniel Levy. It’s clear the wider game discounts a Spurs failure, blaming the club’s instability rather than the manager’s ability. Some clubs even see an opportunity to land a high-quality manager on a reduced package after a dismissal by Spurs.

Spurs also tend to hire managers with an established reputation rather than someone fresh off the coaching line, so there is a reputation to fall back on. Frank did well at Brentford, and Palace will have looked to that experience in judging his suitability for the job at Selhurst Park. There is also an element of better fit for a number of these sacked Spurs coaches. Nuno and Frank were never going to work at Spurs stylistically, but at Forest, West Ham and Crystal Palace their philosophies are far more likely to be accepted.

It’s worth noting that failure at Spurs isn’t always just a blip in a career. Sherwood and Postecoglou both struggled spectacularly in the jobs that immediately followed, and Mourinho’s stock has been on a near-constant downward trend ever since he left (excluding a UEFA Conference League title).

So perhaps the real question isn’t why Spurs managers keep finding work, but why they so rarely find success in N17 first. Roberto De Zerbi arrived with a reputation to rival any of his predecessors and a five-year contract to go with it. If he ends up as the next name on this list, the rest of football will no doubt find him another job. Spurs fans would much rather he never needed one.

Enjoyed this?

Get The Football Faculty Briefing twice a month: our best Spurs writing, the big issues in the game, and what’s worth reading elsewhere.

Leave a Reply