Predicting a Roberto De Zerbi team sheet has become a lottery, and yesterday’s was no exception. The Italian made six changes from the defeat at Leeds United, with the likes of Micky van de Ven and Andy Robertson dropping to the bench.
The changes seem largely vindicated, with Spurs cruising to a comfortable 2-0 victory capped by an impressive first league start from Luca Williams-Barnett, who was himself part of the raft of changes.
This was the 34th change De Zerbi has made to his starting XI in just 11 league games, almost double the Premier League average and more than any other manager in the division. Bournemouth have made just six all season. At Chelsea, his compatriot Claudio Ranieri famously earned the “Tinkerman” nickname, and it wasn’t meant kindly. But with Spurs on the rise and the shifting line-up seemingly working, is De Zerbi reframing what it means to be a Tinkerman?
Why so many changes?
Firstly, it’s worth being clear that the variability of the Spurs line-up isn’t purely by design. Spurs have had, and continue to manage, one of the largest injury crises in the Premier League. The most notable long-term absentees have included Xavi Simons, Dejan Kulusevski, James Maddison and now Mathys Tel. It’s hardly a surprise, therefore, that the attack has seen the most upheaval, and that’s before we consider the unavailability of new signings Sávio and Mykhailo Mudryk. In this area of the pitch, De Zerbi has had to rotate simply because the availability of players has been so inconsistent.

Spurs have been able to absorb these injuries thanks to a larger and deeper squad, built on a summer of record spending and transfer-window ambition. Injuries aside, De Zerbi has needed to rotate just to keep players fit and engaged in the first team. This is a squad built for runs in multiple competitions, and until Spurs start their FA Cup campaign in January, the fixture list is notably thin.
Pundits have largely seen this as an opportunity for Spurs, who should stay fresher in the second half of the season while other teams are ground down by attrition. Bournemouth are balancing European football, and their settled first team could come back to bite them as a smaller squad is gradually worn down by the weight of games.
It’s also easy to forget that De Zerbi is still early in his Spurs tenure. He hasn’t yet been able to fully assess the squad he inherited, let alone the new arrivals from the summer. Rotation and tinkering are allowing the Italian to make a considered judgement on his players, and it has genuinely felt like an iterative process in the early weeks: learning by trying different combinations of players and tweaking the overall system. Despite a clear overarching philosophy, Spurs have also varied their shape from game to game. The systems used against Coventry and Leeds, for example, required very different personnel and made changes necessary. That game-to-game tweaking is unlikely to stop even once the overall style is settled, so expect more changes for the trip to Sunderland next weekend.
Why are the changes working?
The most convincing evidence is that Spurs have played better when De Zerbi has changed the most, not worse. In the four league games after five or more changes (Newcastle, Manchester United, Coventry and Ipswich), Spurs took seven points from 12 and outscored opponents by 0.87 expected goals per game. Both of Spurs’ six-change line-ups produced their strongest performances on the numbers: a 1-1 draw at Old Trafford in which they created twice as much as United, and yesterday’s 2-0 win over Ipswich, in which they recorded 2.65 xG and allowed just 0.47. Meanwhile, Spurs’ worst display of their recent run, the 1-0 defeat at Leeds, came after a single change.
The reason is that the core of the side and the way it plays have stayed constant, even as the names around them change. Antonín Kinský and Jan Paul van Hecke have started all 11 league games and Sandro Tonali 10, giving Spurs a settled spine (although Tonali missed yesterday’s game through illness). Possession has been 58% or higher in 10 of the 11 games, whoever has started, which suggests the players coming in understand exactly what De Zerbi wants. A £300m-plus summer also means the player coming in is often as good as the one going out, easing any fear that changes will lower the quality on the pitch.
None of this means De Zerbi should keep tinkering forever. As the injury list clears, Spurs will need a settled first XI if they’re going to sustain a push for Europe through the winter, and there’s a fine line between rotation that keeps a squad sharp and change that stops a team building understanding.
For now, though, the evidence says the changes are a strength rather than a weakness. Ranieri spent his Chelsea years being mocked as the Tinkerman, and a decade later his rotations helped win Leicester the league. De Zerbi hopefully won’t need quite as long to prove his point at Spurs.
Leave a Reply